The Bench Has No Bad Days: Britain's Villagers Are Reviewing Home Like Tourists
Photo: USEPA Environmental-Protection-Agency, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Type the name of almost any British village into TripAdvisor and you will find two kinds of reviews. The first is from someone passing through: a brisk four stars for the tea room, a note about parking. The second is from someone who lives there, and they are reviewing the bench.
Not the tea room. Not the church. The bench. 'Five stars,' writes one reviewer in a village outside Norwich. 'Good sightlines. No wasps in October. The wood has been treated.' Another, from a hamlet in the Peak District, gives the bus shelter four stars: 'Shelter is sound. Timetable is a work of fiction.'
This is not a joke, exactly. It is a joke with a straight face, which is a different thing. Across the UK, locals are using TripAdvisor as a place to review their own towns — not as tourists, but as self-appointed civic critics. They rate the village green, the roundabout, the post box, the quality of the silence after 9pm. The reviews are lovingly pedantic. They are also, in their own odd way, a record of how local life actually feels.
The Five-Star Bus Shelter
'We are not trying to be funny,' says Martin, 61, who reviews under the name ParishWatcher and has lived in the same village for thirty years. 'We are trying to be accurate. The bench has good sightlines. That is a fact.' Martin has reviewed eleven benches in his area. He has a system. Comfort, outlook, proximity to a bin, and whether the bench faces the road or away from it. 'A bench that faces the road is a bench for nosy people,' he says. 'A bench that faces away is a bench for people who want to think. Both are valid.'
The reviews are not exclusive to benches. Bus shelters come in for serious critique. One reviewer in Cumbria gave her local shelter three stars and noted that the glass was 'smeary but the timetable is laminated, which shows ambition'. A reviewer in Devon praised a village green for its 'even grass and low dog traffic', then deducted a star for the bins. 'The bins are fine,' she wrote. 'It is the people who use them.'
A Love Letter With Footnotes
What looks like silliness is usually affection wearing a costume. The villagers are not mocking their home. They are describing it with the intensity of people who have noticed every detail because they have nowhere else to look. A five-star review of a roundabout is not a review of a roundabout. It is a review of a place that has become familiar enough to be funny.
'It started as a joke,' says Sonia, 39, who reviews under MuddyBootsMum. 'I reviewed the roundabout because someone had put a traffic cone on it and it looked like a hat. Then people started asking me which bench was best. Now I get messages.' Sonia has reviewed the village hall, the car park and a particularly well-maintained hedge. 'I gave the hedge five stars. It is a good hedge. It does what a hedge should do.'
There is a genre logic to this. TripAdvisor is built for strangers. It asks: what is this place like for someone who has never been here? The local reviewer answers a different question: what is this place like when you have been here every day for twenty years? The result is a review that reads like a love letter with footnotes. 'The green is lovely,' one writes. 'However, the bench is positioned at an angle that suggests it was installed by someone who has never sat down.'
The Roundabout Is the Main Character
In some villages, the roundabout has become the main character. One review describes a roundabout in Oxfordshire as 'well-signposted, good camber, no boy racers on a Tuesday'. Another, in Suffolk, gives five stars to a village sign and two stars to the road surface beside it. 'The sign is charming,' the reviewer writes. 'The road is a rumour.'
This is where hyperlocal pride meets the world's most reviewable website, and the collision is mostly harmless. TripAdvisor's guidelines ask reviewers to write about their own experience. Locals have experience in abundance. They have visited the bench in all weathers. They have opinions about the bus shelter that predate the internet. The platform does not quite know what to do with them, so it files them alongside reviews of the Louvre and a steakhouse in Orlando. The village green gets a ranking. The ranking is meaningless. The review is not.
The Local Critic's Dilemma
The volunteers are careful. Most give four or five stars. 'I always give five stars,' says Elaine, 54, who reviewed her village green and then felt guilty about the bins. 'It is not a review. It is a defence.' There is a fear of being the person who dragged the village down to 4.2. There is also a fear of being too nice. 'If you give everything five stars, people stop reading,' says Martin. 'You have to be honest. The bus shelter is not perfect. The glass is smeary.'
The reviews are not changing tourism. No one is booking a holiday to see a bench in Norfolk. But they are changing something smaller. They are a way of saying: I live here. I have looked. I have noticed. The bench has no bad days. The weather does. Five stars.